Considering laser eye surgery for the first time can be overwhelming. There’s a lot of information to understand and digest, such as the difference between the two most popular laser eye surgery techniques – LASIK vs PRK. Though the final decision comes after an assessment and discussion between you and your surgeon, here are the basic differences and similarities between LASIK surgery and PRK surgery.
LASIK vs PRK: the Similarities
Both LASIK and PRK are forms of laser eye surgery, a type of refractive operation. They both aim to surgically and permanently correct an eye’s prescription, typically for long-distance sight. This is achieved by reshaping the cornea, the front surface of the eye, with an excimer laser. Both techniques are able to correct myopia (short- or near-sightedness), hyperopia (long- or far-sightedness), and astigmatism.
This reshaping process is known as photoablation, the removal of selected areas of corneal tissue through vaporisation. This process is guided by a computer, which has been given your biometric measurements from your pre-operative consultations. By adjusting the curvature of the cornea, the bending, or refraction, of light through this surface is corrected to come to a sharp focus on your retina.
Neither LASIK surgery nor PRK surgery will help you avoid the natural age-related deterioration of your near sight, a condition known as presbyopia. As mentioned earlier, these laser eye surgery techniques are designed to correct your far sight. This means around your mid to late-40s, you will find that while your long-distance vision is still good, you will begin to need glasses for reading and other near work.
LASIK vs PRK: the Differences
When it comes to choosing between LASIK vs PRK, it’s probably the differences between the two that will be the deciding factor. While some people may be suitable for either laser eye surgery technique, others may not meet the eligibility criteria for one or the other, making the choice simpler. Here are some of the major distinguishing factors between the two procedures.
LASIK surgery
LASIK stands for laser-assisted in situ keratomileusis. Its main distinction from PRK surgery is that a thin hinged flap of tissue is created from the uppermost layers of the cornea. This flap can be created with a bladed instrument called a microkeratome or with another type of laser, known as a femtosecond laser. The corneal flap is flipped open to the side of the cornea, which exposes the deeper layers for photoablation with the excimer laser. After this, the flap is folded back over, and will self-seal in place during the healing process. LASIK can take up to half an hour to treat both eyes.
After the operation, you’ll be fitted with protective plastic shields over your eyes and given post-operative instructions. Immediately after LASIK surgery, you can expect:
- Significantly clearer sight within a day after your surgery
- Some glare sensitivity
- Seeing haloes around lights, particularly at night time
- Your eyes to feel a bit sore, gritty, or itchy
- Mild redness
You’ll be able to return to gentle, sedentary activities such as reading, watching TV, or deskwork within a couple of days. However, more vigorous activities such as the gym may take a few more days. If you enjoy rougher activities such as contact sports or if your vocation involves a risk of head or facial trauma, you may need to take at least a month off. This is because LASIK involves the unique risk of flap-related complications. Though rare, the corneal flap has the potential to dislodge or catch debris beneath it. In fact, certain occupations may be a consideration against LASIK. Such occupations can include the military or professional athletes in contact sports.
PRK surgery
PRK is different to LASIK surgery in the way that a corneal flap is not required. Instead, only the uppermost layer of the cornea, the epithelium, is removed in a process called debridement. There are a number of techniques that can be used to achieve this, including using an instrument to scrape away the cells (under anaesthesia), using a rotating brush, or using an alcohol solution to loosen the epithelium before scraping it away. Once the epithelium has been removed, the excimer laser can be applied to the underlying tissues for photoablation. The PRK operation typically takes around 15 minutes for both eyes.
After PRK surgery, you will have a bandage contact lens placed over your corneas. The contact lens helps support the regeneration of the epithelial cells and improves comfort during your recovery period. The PRK recovery process is longer than that for LASIK due to the epithelial debridement. While LASIK can result in clear sight within 24 hours, you may find yourself blurry after PRK for at least a week. Full recovery after PRK typically takes a month. While your eyes are healing, you can expect to feel some pain and discomfort, for which your surgeon can prescribe painkillers. You may also experience some glare sensitivity and haloes around lights.
Because PRK doesn’t require the creation of a corneal flap, it is more suitable for people with thinner corneas who would otherwise be ineligible for LASIK. As there are also other eligibility criteria applicable to both laser eye surgery techniques, book an appointment with your surgeon for a consultation or call on (03) 9070 5788.
Note: Any surgical or invasive procedure carries risks. Before proceeding, you should seek a second opinion from an appropriately qualified health practitioner.
References
PRK vs LASIK.
https://www.webmd.com/eye-health/prk-vs-lasik#:~:text=Both%20LASIK%20and%20PRK%20use,which%20grows%20back%20over%20time.
What’s the difference between PRK and LASIK?
https://www.healthline.com/health/eye-health/prk-vs-lasik
LASIK eye surgery recovery: what to expect.
https://www.webmd.com/connect-to-care/lasik/what-to-expect-from-lasik-surgery-recovery
PRK surgery recovery: what you can expect
https://www.webmd.com/connect-to-care/lasik/what-to-expect-from-prk-surgery-recovery